why did castiel break sam's wall

In Hunteri Heroici, Sam and Castiel make a connection when Sam is talking about living in a dream. Or, at least, no memory since the time that he stumbled out of the river "drenched and confused and unclothed" and was found by a nondescript, supposedly Christian woman. Once John is sent back and history is corrected, the real Castiel returns to the bunker where he meets the Winchesters and asks what occurred as Sam and Dean promised to explain. Castiel brings up the possibility that Alastair was lying, but Sam shoots it down. Death erected a psychological wall inside Sam's mind to serve as a blockade between Sam and his memories of his time in the cage, as his time there was so horrific that remembering what happened would mess him up severely. In When the Levee Breaks, it is Castiel who lets Sam out of the panic room. In Reading Is Fundamental, Sam thanks Castiel for helping him and taking on his hell. Though it is clear, he does miss his friend. Similar to Dean's case, Castiel even raised Sam from perdition on his own will. Welcome to SFFSE! Effect of a "bad grade" in grad school applications. We know it was Castiel who broke into Lucifer's cage to release Sam's body, but has it ever been explained how he done this? The reason this is significant is because archangels don't possess bodies -- they're "all soul" -- so it's likely that whatever Castiel did to get Sam out was only capable of extracting the physical part. Sam asked about his mother and Castiel can only reveal she's alive but knows very little of her wellbeing. Later on, an alternate version of Castiel is created as a result of John Winchester being pulled out of the past. But to me, "The Born-Again Identity" exemplified all the things that "Supernatural" does best: emphasizing the brotherly bond that holds the show together; highlighting the excellence of the supporting characters; showcasing the dramatic chops of its actors; and proving that an emotional through-line is all it really takes to make a story resonate. By entering your email and clicking Sign Up, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. When he and Dean got fooled by the trickster, Sam realized Castiel's warning and the trickster's familiarity was a sign that the latter was angel. During Prophet and Loss, Sam secretly told Cass about Dean's plan to lock himself in a Ma'lak Box, in spite of Dean telling him not to. Castiel soon discovers that losing the grace is causing Sam to start to revert to the state he was in before Gadreel possessed him, but Sam insists they keep going as he wants to make up for his past which Castiel reluctantly agrees to. During Beat the Devil, they journey to Apocalypse World and travel through a tunnel filled with vampires. There's also something a little icky, in a non-consensual sense, about the possibility that amnesiac Cas was married, given how entirely freaked out he was about the prospect of losing his virginity back in "Free To Be You And Me." Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Sam gets a memory of Elanor bleeding in the alley. The answer is still no, because Sam is my friend. He kills Tortured Sam and his body seizes out of control. This Castiel appeared on Earth with Alternate Zachariah, who was angry about the fact that somebody's been messing with time. How did God resurrect Castiel if he has no power of the Empty? Meanwhile, Sams wall in his mind broke. When Sam is taken, Castiel goes after him but is too late and he stops Dean from the sight of his devoured brother, knowing it would horrify him. Which language's style guidelines should be used when writing code that is supposed to be called from another language? Some time after The Darkness was released, Sam is reunited with a sick Castiel and helps the angel search for his "crappy" car. Remember how Raphael intended to do the same, but to release Michael and Lucifer instead? After Crowley provides Castiel with extra grace, Castiel rushes to the bunker to rescue Sam from a murderous Dean Winchester. Which means others could know secrets. Death puts a wall up in Sam's mind so that he will not remember Hell. This week's episode, "The Born-Again Identity", not only re-introduced Castiel and Misha Collins to the show, but it also reminded me why I love Supernatural. Misha Collins did masterful work in this episode, finding so many subtle nuances between Emmanuel and Castiel that it was a joy to watch him reinterpret the familiar character once again. When these attachments broke, Lucifer's Cage was immediately opened and he was released. After killing Zachariah, Sam uses the sigil to send Cass off when Castiel overpowers Dean and beats him to a bloody pulp. He chooses to spare Dean and Bobby, refusing to give up the souls because he has Raphaels followers to deal with. In A Little Slice of Kevin, Sam is surprised to see Castiel, but is happy to see an old friend. When Sam tries to get more information, Castiel angrily replies "What part of I don't know escapes your understanding?" Why did he wanted the soul to remain in hell since he's obviously capable of retrieving a part of Sam from hell in the first place? Sam even deduced that Jack had a part in bringing Castiel back before he embraces Castiel after confirming that his friend has truly returned. Season 4 Castiel, a seraph, was able to split the wall by touching Sam's head, meaning the wall must've not been that strong. However, the attempt was a failure. What did you think of "The Born-Again Identity"? He stared at the wall. Castiel has nearly finished healing Sam and when he goes to give him his next treatment, he discovers that Sam still has some of Gadreel's grace inside him. Despite being surprised, Castiel gives Crowley the demon blood, allowing Crowley and Raphael to complete the ritual to open the door to Purgatory, despite Bobby and Dean trying to stop them. Later on, Castiel seemingly threatens Crowley to get Sam's soul back, but when Crowley says he can't, Castiel toasts Crowley's bones. Sam then learns from the angel that he returned from the cage but without his soul for a full year. Never trust a demon! The simple fact is the cage has never been properly explained on the show, including how to get in and out of it (And, let's be honest, I doubt the writers have given it much thought). As of Lebanon, Sam along with Dean mentions Castiel to John Winchester after he was pulled out of the past and he was amazed they live with an angel. They soon succeed in removing the Mark of Dean but at the cost of freeing The Darkness. Castiel gave different blood and completed his own ritual. I remember that only in the final episode of season 6, Castiel confessed that it was he who brought Sam back from the cage, but it did not seem to say why it turned out to be just a body without a soul. Unfortunately, Sam's soul was left in the cage. Castiel has plans for Crowley but doesnt need Raphael and kills Raphael. We seemed to gloss over Castiel's Lucifer problem, Sam and Dean leaving and Meg joining the hospital staff a little too rapidly, as if the episode was stuffed too full to really give those ideas time to breathe. The episode is titled ' The French Mistake ' and takes place in the sixth season. It's true that Jensen Ackles could probably have on-screen chemistry with a potted plant, but he really brings his A-game when playing scenes with Collins in a different, but equally compelling way from his effortless rhythm with Padalecki, since Dean and Cas have such an odd, symbiotic relationship that has helped them both evolve and rediscover their faith over the past few seasons. In "First Born," Castiel stays with Sam in the bunker, trying to enjoy human things such as a sandwich but having a hard time as an angel. Despite sharing a desire to defeat Lucifer and save Sam, Castiel wasn't keen on the idea of Dean letting Alternate Michael possess him, knowing that once Lucifer was dead, Michael would take full control of Dean and they would be dealing with the same threat posed by Lucifer only this time by Michael. Dean and Bobby find Castiel and Crowley. "The Man Who Knew Too Much" - Jim Beaver as Bobby, Jensen Ackles as Dean, Jared Padalecki as Sam in SUPERNATURAL on The CW. Sam is confused by this. Castiel looks at Sam's hand, unsure what do with it. While waiting to see if it will work, Castiel reassures Dean. It only makes the brothers' situation more agonizing, since both are barely holding on by a thread, clearly feeling too exhausted to go on, but forcing themselves to serve the greater good as long as they're still breathing, since it's the only thing they know how to do. @Dvij I don't think so. Welcome to SFFSE! They don't see each other much after that. I, actually, agree with you on this. Sam looked to Castiel to see if Anna's plan would work, though Castiel disagreed. Sam asked if Castiel was sent to Heaven but he tells them that he was put in The Empty as he describes his horrible experience in the void of nothingness. This was the least of their concern after they learn of Lucifer's return. The bar is closed, but the bartender, Robin, agrees to help Sam to figure out who he is and where he should be. Castiel tries to feel Sam's soul, only to find out Sam doesn't have one. To his horror, Kelly accepts that Lucifer is the child's father but runs away instead of aborting it. After he was killed by the Archangel Raphael, Castiel was resurrected by God and joined Sam, Dean, and Bobby Singer in a quest to prevent the brothers from becoming the vessels of Michael and Lucifer. It instead focused on our characters' internal struggles, reminding us that no matter how dire the circumstances, our heroes are always driven by the desire to do the right thing, no matter the personal cost. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. I found Marin's defeated attitude particularly interesting in regards to the way it mirrored Dean's story this season. When Dean decides to say 'yes' to Michael in Point of No Return, Sam brings Castiel along to help him stop Dean. It's Me, Dean Winchester, Sam was excited to hear from Dean about meeting an actual Angel and wasn't skeptical like his brother as he believed in them. However, this Castiel has no recollection of Sam and attacks the Winchesters on Zachariah's orders. He also remembers that Robin was one of his victims and she disappears when he apologizes for not actually helping her, and he learns that theres another version of Sam out there. When Michael broke in the bunker, Sam was worried after Castiel fought Michael and was promptly overpowered by him. Sam asks them if angels are supposed to show mercy. Dean persistently argues that this is not the case, and Sam, hoping his own beliefs are untrue, has assisted in every attempt made to rescue Castiel. Sam was amused about the prospect of him, Cass, Dean, and Jack being able to retire from hunting if their success keeps up. Due to Dean's anger at Castiel, Castiel opted to work with Sam instead and they fought against the zombies side-by-side effectively, holding until Belphegor completed his spell. During Proverbs 17:3, unlike Dean, Sam doesn't blame Castiel for Rowena's death and tries to call him but he won't answer.