In a radio interview from 1970 about the Beatles breakup, J talks briefly ostensibly about Epsteins death, then says the album they made after the trauma (& lowers his voice and Yoko laughs) was Sergeant Peppers, oh Im not sure: joke for no-one but Yoko, or revelation going by so fast its almost unnoticeable by mixing stories? In 1971 movie Imagine, perhaps freed by USA breaking story of PID, George corrects J jokingly, a bit nervously, hiding his mouth with his napkin a bit, saying The Fab 3 when J had been riffing on The Fab 4. A robust conspiracy theory, like official theories, leaves nothing out; everything can be explained within its parameters. Who is to say that the audience, obsessed with clue-hunting, wasnt benefiting from a masculine scream of horror that was the reversal of Beatlemanias female orgiastic scream? Between 6 and 19 November 1966, McCartney and his girlfriend Jane Asher were on holiday, travelling through France and Kenya. The magazines cover featured Paul and Linda with their children, in a picture taken on their Scottish farm. That story about the Moroccan student doesnt even make sense from the claims the student makes came out way later, could be a cover story, could be an unrelated incident, etc. So conviction itself (even if it IS right, that he looks the same or different) is not PROOF formally. Who is to say that the audience, obsessed with clue-hunting, wasnt benefiting from a masculine scream of horror that was the reversal of Beatlemanias female orgiastic scream? The drugs he was taking do not seem to explain those changes, he was not ravaged by them the way young people who change dramatically under their effects change their features. In September 1969, an article entitled "Is Beatle Paul McCartney Dead?" Billy Shears was an alias for Ringo Starr and was used as the announcement/segue for Ringo's song "With a Little Help from my Friends" on the Sergeant Pepper Album. Before 1966 Paul had dark brown eyes. The legend goes that in 1965 (one year before McCartney is said to have died) young Shears entered a Beatles lookalike competition organised by the band's manager Brian Epstein, in the . But he is not Paulie. He cited many clues which further escalated the story. I just wish detraction statements would be more carefully thought through. However, the purported clone's birth name and birthplace may vary depending on the source; per Musicoholics, he was a Canadian man named William Shears Campbell. He supposedly won the Paul lookalike competition. Once exposed to PID, it became possible for me to read all of the Beatles latter output, at the level of pure text, as one extended lament over Pauls death and their guilty conscience about the coverup. In late 1969, American college campuses were roiled by the anti-war movement, facing the consequences of the election of Richard Nixon and the inevitability of the draft, at the same time as various liberation movements were beginning to find their feet. It confounds me that people feel absolutly no shame in calling Sir Paul a fraud. Billy Shears WKNRs Russ Gibb spoke to Derek Taylor, and to someone else who claimed to be McCartney but was in fact Tony Bramwell. So cut the crap about anything goes here. The Beatles, I would argue, had reached the farthest possible point with their interpretation of music as a counter to political reality, and had exposed, with ". In the case of Paul McCartneys replacement, his noble and selfless deed surely saved the lives of who knows how many across the planet? Fred LaBour says his review was satirical and admitted making up most of the details. You may be well aware of that, but it does need to be pointed out in general. There was a winner though, from Edinburgh, named William Campbell. However, it contains a general narrative regarding the Paul McCartney story which could actually be true right down to the exact dates and details. A little over 50 years ago, on Nov. 9, 1966 (9/11 in British usage), Paul McCartney was decapitated in a car crash, and was soon replaced, unbeknownst to the public, by a lookalike with equal or better musical abilities, the impostor Faul we have lived with till today. in particular yields a rich overlay of meaning, and everywhere the apparent gibberish becomes illuminating, a piercing cry of grief that is the perfect antidote to the earlier Beatlemania. The Paul Is Dead myth began in 1969, and alleged that Paul McCartney died in 1966. Also: what of this claim by C. Bowin, about totally different earlobes (among other changes) makes you so defensive as to ignore the point? That is the point of PID. Talk:William Shears Campbell - Wikipedia The man we know today as Sir Paul McCartney is actually Faul, who has done an outstanding job of impersonation for twice the length of the original Pauls lifespan. Coming in at third place at 23% was the urban legend of Paul McCartney's supposed car crash death.We could go on about the "clues" in Beatles songs that allegedly corroborated the "Paul is dead" rumor and the claim that he was replaced by one William "Billy Shears" Campbell the same guy referenced in the first two songs of "Sgt. I doubt we will ever be told in a straight forward way but it certainly makes you go, hmm. The article below, as it turns out, was published by a tabloid-styled, faux-journalism website by the name ofWorld News Daily Report. Who knows, but one way or another, left. So, either Paul is dead, or the Beatles crashed against the limitations of popular music as agent of change after the highly engineered sound of "Sgt. PID consumers all but seem to desire Pauls death. Yet in this rumor there is huge discrepancy in the facts. I cannot think of any historical recounting that has so much certainty as to facts and what did or did not happen to Paul. One thing is for certain that I know as a fan, the rumor was going round in London in 1967. I dont know, you know as much about it as me No, that was bullshit, the whole thing was made up. One way or another, there is a 5th Beatle, friend and interloper at the same time. Billy Shears . The earliest reference is in text, a disclaimer in Englands then UK-only Beatles Monthly in February 1967. The Best Hoax of All: What Happened To Paul McCartney - Musicoholics Its impossible to even briefly mention here some of the key aural and visual clues, but Andru J. Reeves good-humoredly skeptical ", (1994) is a good place to start. Indeed, it often provides a deeper, more profound, more satisfying systematization, as wholesome as official narrative. The moment I walk in the door, he's asking me how my drive over was in that famous Liverpudlian accent, but he stops himself . I better go hide that shovel. Beatles handler Mal Evans inexplicable death , is said to have occurred because hed finished writing a memoir about the Beatles; the manuscript of that book, ". Thats why. Conspiracy theory, to counter elite science, always enacts pseudo-science in a populist vein; its methods are technological, its procedures deductive, its empiricism its only saving grace just like the official sciences of empire. There is now a massive body of forensic proof, anecdotal testimony, scientific photograph assessment, comparative voice analysis, circumstantial evidence, etc. Who is Billy Shears? - Encyclopedia of Opinion - Parlia In fact, the crash never happened. In fact, he may have enjoyed very much getting the truth out, even with the putatively joking freaks in the line. Dates, times and brand of car, it is all nailed down to perfection. Lennon-McCartneys words, in. The following month a paragraph appeared in the February 1967 edition of the Beatles Book Monthly magazine, headed FALSE RUMOUR: Although the magazine downplayed the incident, and claimed the car was in McCartneys possession. Proponents slide 1 of 1 Matt Tamanini Editor and Producer at True Crime Obsessed "His name is Billy Shears." 18 June 2019 Premises [P1] Paul McCartney died in a car crash in 1966. About Epstein: it may well have been pressures about Pauls death also pushing that near break-up. Then again, like Lennon, Paul McCartney never really diedgenetically speaking. Look it up. The acclaimed Amazon bestsellerRiding So High The Beatles and Drugs By the creator of the Beatles Bible.Buy now:Paperback | Ebook . He is a talented man (some say not so, but I prefer to recognize that though different, it made the Beatles trajectory what we have in the end, and it worked out). EMI would not have allowed him to die either. Just as literary (deconstructive) textual analysis takes us to conflicts that resonate with us -- sub-rosa clashes of morality enacted by the critic in alliance with the reader (with the artistic creator standing at a distance) -- conspiracy theory, with its proliferation of endless clues, allows us an alternative route of access to the deeper meaning of history. I am old enough to remember the Beatles in the few years before their breakup and I remember even then thinking of how Paul had changed in the space of a few short yrs. So it is no surprise that it was at large Midwestern universities in the United States that PID really took off; the British were never as influenced by it, perhaps because they could regularly see the Beatles in London, especially as Paul and John became involved in avant-garde happenings once they stopped touring for good in 1966. In Come Together a reference to Walrus gumboot on the man with the disease, spine cracked, ju-ju eyeballs, flat-top, monkey finger, and so on, link that apparition with Walrus AND with Beatles (Beatle Boots are little black gumboots they popularized early on). In his revealing Rolling Stone interview in 1970, John Lennon was asked about the death story. The complete guide to The Beatles 'Paul Is Dead' myth - Far Out Magazine (SOMEBODY created them, and SOMEBODY (probably Lennon) had to ok them for inclusion in the album packages (and then set about to orchestrate their discovery as a way to generate interest + sell more albums? It is the source for Billy's Back!, Beatles Enlightenment, and The Talent Contest, and also includes nine chapters that were not selected for those compilations. 168K views 8 years ago A hidden camera catches the moment John Lennon convinces Faul McCartney (AKA Billy Shears AKA William Campbell) that taking The Deceased Paul McCartneys place in The. Paul McCartney 'replaced by body double after death' claims bizarre Also has good taste in music and smells nice.. The application of the toolbox of scientific rationality toward accelerated, almost incomprehensible, social change is only superficially similar. Lifes too short (though Pauls hasnt been). Whether to trust their affairs to rapacious but effective agent Allen Klein or Pauls well-heeled father-in-law Lee Eastman (both New Yorkers) was a big reason for the groups unraveling. The Wondrous Light of Truth - Dilara Esengil The Beatles were no longer propagating nave love anthems, giving voice to teenage female angst, deriving inspiration from early '60s girl groups like the Shirelles and the Ronettes and making it more musically sophisticated. It would, instead, seem as though Jane did a charade for a while, perhaps even turning for comfort to the new man. Official history has much to say about this. I dont think Paul is dead, but I do think the Beatles added fuel to the fire. The caller, identified only as Tom, claimed that McCartney was dead, and instructed Gibb to play Revolution 9 backwards, where the repeated number nine phrase was heard as turn me on, dead man. Beyond mere belief opinion; but as long as it was, the case remained hypothesis as much as PIA is an hypothesis, strictly speaking. So will the true conspiracy behind his death and cover up, as well as his purposeful replacement. Billy Shears replaced Paul and the rest, as they say, is history PAUL'S REPLACEMENT - BILLY SHEARS. Then learn the other circumstantial arguments either way. Love David Bowie? Actually Doctor Robert (ha ha): Per the Mal Evans single page shown in The Winged Beatle, John was distraught that it was really happening & how good the surgery was, that Paul had been to the clinic in Kenya which had done a good job. I wonder why it is so imporatnt for some of you to believe this myth. It is mere emotion which drives your comment. Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by Sam, Mar 25, 2010. You have no proof, only conjecture, and this has been going nowhere for far too long. ", "Confronting American Fascism" and ""A Radical Human Rights Approach to the Immigration 'Problem.'" One reason could be that Paul was the most androgynous of the group, and his transformation (especially in the midst of his intellectual takeover of the Beatles) was the most marked, both visually and musically. Thus we assimilate death not banally or procedurally, but as a matter of impossible, endlessly deferred detection. McCartney travelled with Jagger in the latters Mini Cooper, while Hadjij drove in McCartneys Mini. A recent mockumentary, in the alleged voice of George Harrison (available at Netflix), covers the territory in an over-the-top manner, inciting doubt. The Beatles may have had a lot to say about the social changes of the early 1960s, but the new political realities were of a more intractable nature; the Beatles, with their wives and mansions, must have started to look pretty tame by then. It involves the producers and consumers of art in a complicit relationship. Conspiracy theory is excess, or rather impossible containment of excess. For a year and a half or almost two, he does NOT PLAY on camera. To counter such elite manipulation, the resulting form of anti-conspiracy agency may be demented, but it is agency nonetheless; Donald Trumps presidency, we might argue, is nothing more than the sum of all the postwar conspiracy theories, yet this agglomeration has actually managed to seize power. In September 1969, American college students published a series of articles in which they claimed that clues to McCartneys death could be found among the lyrics and artwork of the Beatles recordings. This interview was originally published in the May 2017 print edition of The Avocado and is now made available online for the first time. Similarly, the "Pepper" cover, arguably the most famous in the history of records, allows much creative interpretation. However, when one is familiar with the case (and has seen forever the difference, not in some haphazard way though some people really are only seeing it that way), one looks at Asher and the post-Epstein death differently. PID became a way for the counterculture, running against its own limits, to announce its premature death to itself. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=317yvBXrXjw 3. In 1966, James Paul McCartney was killed in a car crash and replaced with a double; a session musician by the name William Shears Campbell. (Without them, it went on for a few more years, in a self-conscious though depleted way.) In my opinion, acid head people are also called dead people; when Paul finally took LSD, John probably said now, Paul is dead, at last or something, h? '", "A History of the Cat in Nine Chapters or Less". The Beatles Bible is run for the love of anything and everything to do with The Beatles. To spare the public from grief, the Beatles replaced him with a man named William Shears Campbell, who wasthe winner of a McCartney look-alike contest and who happened to have the same kind of jovial personality as Paul. In fact, the intention fits without stretching it at all, in the other case. Seems to be mixing griefs about Paul & Eppie for those in the know. For PID theorists, the question remains as to how a musician as talented as Paul could ever be replaced, with the alleged impostor perhaps even more successful than the original. CRAP! Why Paul, though? For instance, the disclaimer (or disclaimer) in Feb. 1967 mentions car crash, Paul, death (and some wrong and deflective info). So, either Paul is dead, or the Beatles crashed against the limitations of popular music as agent of change after the highly engineered sound of "Sgt. William Shears Campbell | Fictspedia Wiki | Fandom Sometimes known as theRock and Roll Revolution, this global movement respected no boundaries and utilized the universal language of music (and English) to transform the entire planetary civilization. cover, arguably the most famous in the history of records, allows much creative interpretation. Paul McCartney announces Eyes Of The Storm book and exhibition, Paul McCartney announces The 7 Singles Box, Revolver to be reissued with remixes and rarities, The Beatles: Get Back wins five Emmy Awards, Brian Epstein statue unveiled in Liverpool, Join the Fab Forum discussion on The 'Paul is dead' myth, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FsPCQ932vlU, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=317yvBXrXjw, disclaimer in Englands then UK-only Beatles Monthly, Paul McCartney live: Climate Pledge Arena, Seattle, Paul McCartney live: Olympic Stadium, Seoul, South Korea, Television: John Lennon and Yoko Ono are interviewed for How Late It Is, Paul McCartney, Bob Dylan and The Rolling Stones visit Dollys nightclub, London, The Beatles arrive in Amesbury, Wiltshire, Paul McCartney, Jane Asher, Ringo Starr and Maureen Cox fly to Lisbon, John and Cynthia Lennon, George Harrison and Pattie Boyd fly to Hawaii, The "Incredibly Impossible to Derail This Thread" thread, Beatles Hangman (nothing to get hung about), John Lennon attends the 14 Hour Technicolour Dream, NME Poll-Winners' show: The Beatles' final UK concert, Recording, mixing: Let It Be, You Know My Name (Look Up The Number). He described many of the clues pointing towards the story being true, and the story rapidly became an international phenomenon. . RINGO STARR CLAIMS THE REAL PAUL MCCARTNEY DIED IN 1966 AND WAS REPLACED BY LOOK-ALIKE. When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, However, he continued, if I was dead, Im sure Id be the last to know.. Fifty years on from 1967 and the Summer of Love, 'Shears' is a squeaky-clean Anglican chaplain, nursing memories of a lost and secret love. It was originally going to be Glenn Campbell, with two Ns, and then I said thats too close, nobodyll buy that. New clue: Flowers In The Dirt by Faul is a reference to Paul being dead, and the red background signifies the dirt of mars, which is a reference to the moon landing, which was obviously faked. He actually came back with the rest of the Beatles, but to avoid being caught by Campbell who tried to kidnap him, he disguised himself as Cynthia, when John realized, he decided to help George escape by getting a divorce, but in order to fake Cynthia, after George had left, he convinced Yoko to pretend to be Cynthia and hired William Shears has the best of the Memoirs' "Paul is Dead" material (excluding those . Paul McCartney finally explains cover-up over rumours he died and was McCartney parodied the rumours with the title and cover or his 1993 album Paul Is Live. He said he had been dubbed the new Laird when he first met his Scottish neighbours, but didnt want to be considered the squire of the district. Pepper album. The purported Mal Evans Living the Beatles Legend (supposedly lost book) page in TWB is at 1:01:00 (overall page shown but bottom blurred), and then 1:01:07 bottom of page shown only, but unblurred. As to your implication that ANYTHING CAN BE INTERPRETED AS A CLUE: Lets look at that: one can of course take anything and MAKE it have meanings of wild associations, but the PID clues, in the main, are pretty obvious: they repeat and have direct reference to Paul at some point. In the eight months leading to the completion of their masterpiece Sgt. You are wrong re. Even after the breakup Paul continued publicly questioning his past reality as a Beatle, and does so to this day, which feeds into the conspiracy theory but also lets us see them as early skeptics of their own charisma. The British MI5 also announced an investigation to determine if an imposter could have indeed posed for 48 years astheMember of the Order of the British Empire,Sir JamesPaul McCartney,during official ceremonies involvingQueen Elizabeth II. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FsPCQ932vlU at 40:05. (In The Winged Beatle the clip is shown, though for effect (and thus makes a literal untruth in the edit, unfortunately) the maker of the movie edits in J winking, which is from later in scene. Pepper"or "Abbey Road" or the "White Album," are not meaningless gibberish. I believe the truth will come out before he dies. Why not John who died secretly? Without proof either way, both were. All images their respective owners. Source: Pinterest. One can decipher innumerable clues, such as Lennons gibberish at the end of Im So Tired, playing backwards as Paul is a dead man! They picked a panoply of historical figures (for example, Aleister Crowley, the influential occultist), whose choice only fed into the PID theory, and they are all at a funeral (or celebration, if we heed Martin), mourning Paul or the Beatles, the yellow hyacinth wreath spelling Paul? and laid out in the form of a left-handed guitar (McCartney is left-handed).