Leaf has been invited to present her work at hundreds of corporate and academic institutions, including Fortune 500 companies and the highest ranked universities in Africa. Fear isnt real, weve made it up When we begin to think toxic thoughts, proteins will begin to grow on the dendrites. Whatever truth is found in Dr Leafs teaching isnt discounted by her lack of qualifications, but the fact that Dr Leaf consistently guilds her academic work and qualifications should ring alarm bells for any Christian who values the truth. Caroline Leaf Quotes (Author of Switch On Your Brain) - Goodreads I stayed with it and they finally got an app that worked. A critique, on the other hand, is a detailed analysis and assessment of something, especially a literary, philosophical, or political theory. Critique is how ideas are tested and knowledge grows. In the Dallas charter schools study, Dr Leafs intervention either disadvantaged the students or showed no significant difference. I wanted to understand what you were saying but I never saw anything written to back up your arguments. Over and over again, Dr Leafs teaching conflicts with modern science. Think, Learn, Succeed Workbook: Understanding and Using Your Mind to I have just started reading Switch on your brain but it bothered me greatly when I saw Joyce Meyer endorsed it. Biblical Meditations. We must activate, this is the kind of faith that will heal. Finally, this is it. Luke 17:2 Dr. Caroline Leaf is a communication pathologist, audiologist, clinical and cognitive neuroscientist with a Masters and PhD in Communication Pathology and a BSc Logopaedics, specializing in cognitive and metacognitive neuropsychology. You think, and then you do, which cycles back to the original thought, changing it, and the thoughts connected to it, in a dynamic interrelationship. She developed her theory (called the Geodesic Information Processing theory) of how we think, build memory, and learn, into tools and processes that have transformed the lives of hundreds of thousands of individuals with Traumatic . But the information which is counter to Dr Leafs teaching is out there and its not just me saying it. Really? Here is a link defining the dangers of this teaching: http://www.gotquestions.org/religious-science.html If your church leaders cant show that Dr Leafs teachings are scientifically and scripturally accurate, then politely ask them why shes been invited to preach from their pulpit or to sell her wares in your church? The information offered in Dr. Her influence continues to grow. Maybe it was just coincidence that I was reading Dr Leafs book at the time but I believe if we use Holy Spirit discernment when reading books/articles or listening to people (regardless of their correctness) God can protect us. Routine screening with the much-maligned pap smear has decreased the death rate from cervical cancer in women by as much as 83% [5]. Think of the main key word in the old message. To wit (in your response to a contributor on this forum) that they had fallen for Dr Leafs humanistic Sci-Fi Fantasy version on egocentrism, or spread the word. Their mindfulness development and mental health were assessed by the Leaf Mind Management (LMM) scale before and after the program. Do your own 21-Day Brain Detox, by Dr. Caroline Leaf, Christian neuroscientist. I will add that today was day six of my wife not taking her meds, and we spent the day figuring out how to get her back on them, as she is now experiencing the consequence of six days without meds. 1 Chronicles 12:32, And of the children of Issachar, which were men that had understanding of the times, to know what Israel ought to do . We assume information to be true because others in authority tell us it is. It is unfortunate. When we turn to the Bible, there seems to be supporting evidence of these thoughts: to be made new in the attitude of your minds; Ephesians 4:23, Set your minds on things that are above, not on things that are on earth. Mental health statistics are more dismal than ever. In academic circles, Dr Leafs research hasnt so much as generated a stale whimper [14]. Thus, the scripture does not prove that our thoughts define us as Dr Leaf would suggest. I would have stopped reading at your exclamatory sentence that Quantum physics prove me thoughts can control matter except that there was nothing more to read, since you didnt bother to actually justify your opinion. We can declare Gods word over our lives. She said this in her 2013 book [1: p35], and several times on her social media streams. I take your point that the truth of a persons message isnt dependent on their qualifications. Home Uncategorized Chris Rosebrough exposes the gnostic Manichean heresy of Dr Caroline Leaf, By churchwatcher on January 7, 2015 ( 1 ). It is clear that whoever came up with this blog is not a true Christian. Its a mirage, a manipulation of messaging and social media. No one is perfectly congruent in everything they say. Here are seven biblical affirmations to invite a healing mindset: Photo Credit: GettyImages/Brian A. Jackson. These new branches can be photographed. When a church brings in a speaker, it does make sense that to a large degree, that they support the teaching, which was my cause for concern. Verse 2 in the NLV version is especially interesting. April 5, 2023. 2 Timothy 1:7 And in her book Switch on your brain [1], she said on page 33, For now, rest in the assurance that what God has empowered you to do with your mind is more powerful and effective than any medication, any threat, any sickness, or any neurological challenge. She frequently lectures toaudiences worldwide, linking scientific principles of the brain to spiritual, intellectual and emotional issues in simple and practical ways. I stand up here saying this with conviction because I have seen this over and over and over in so many different circumstances in this country I worked in Dallas for three years in charter schools, and we found the same thing happening. [13]. Below are some more valuable points from the video above and the Related Website video below. Dr. Caroline Leaf is a world-renowned cognitive neuroscientist, author, and speaker. God leads, but we have to choose to let God lead. I have been an Ernest Christian since 6th November 1989. Again, its up to you if you want to believe the PR narrative of Dr Leafs selfless perfection, but its a facade. Its fine to tear a house down whose foundations you think are not sound. Giving her the benefit of the doubt about her teaching is very gracious, but irrespective, intentionally pretending to be a cognitive neuroscientist, deliberately exaggerating her own qualifications, should have disqualified her a long time ago. Leaf was recently on Janet Parshalls show. Father, Your Word has become a part of me. Caroline Leaf may be a qualified "cognitive neuroscientist with a PhD in Communication Pathology specializing in Neuropsychology". My passion is to help people to improve their thinking and mental state so they can have a fulfilled life. Thank you for your article and your extensive research. According to Dr. Caroline Leaf, "It has been found that 12 minutes of daily focused prayer over an 8 week period can change the brain to such an extent that it can be measured on a brain scan. . In her books, on TV, at churches, and in promotional material, Dr Leaf describes herself as a cognitive neuroscientist. Texas, USA: Inprov, Inc, 2009. Im willing to engage in robust discussion especially when people are overtly hostile, and allow me to pre-emptively state that youre welcome to your opinion on that too. 7 Steps to Renew Your Mind - Hungry Generation QEEG measurements of 11 NeurocycleTM participants were performed before using the NeurocycleTM, after the first 21 days, and after the final 63 days to assess mental health improvements. Anyone who thinks on anything that many times during a period od 63 days will see a change in things. Im going to maintain my stand against Dr Leaf anyway. Completing a PhD that involved a model for learning doesnt make you a cognitive neuroscientist. Thank you for this so much! Throughout this time, Dr. Your brain simply captures what your mind dictates. The Apostle Paul said in Romans 12:2 that we are transformed by the renewing of the mind. Thank you for helping the appreciative reader to keep common sense and respect for science and religious ideals. Rather, the authors say, you need to find a . You say, I still cannot understand what drives you to want to pick apart Carolines work. Without critique, how do Christians see both sides of an argument and make up their own minds? According to Christ, His Apostles and God's Holy Word - Dr Caroline Leaf is a fraud. This view is biblically and scientifically incorrect. [1: p31-32] (Emphasis added). When bumps and lollipops grow into mushrooms, you have built long term memory. Individuals are responsible for the facts and opinions contained in their posts. How Caroline Leaf's your brain after a C3 Woman's conference Though there is the minor problem of her research results not demonstrating any actual change. These topics include: 2. _____, this is a very long and exhaustive topic to discuss over email. Leaf Mind Management (LMM) Scale Validation. And hey, as much as its unpleasant at times, its really interesting to hear the way people judge not just what I do but who I am, based on a series of blog posts. KCM Broadcast Notes April 24-28 2023 - Jesus, the Commander In Chief. There is no better time to introduce these strategies than now. Since the early 1980's she has studied and researched the Mind-Brain connection. The items in red represent exactly what she said! It is discouraging and unfortunate that Dr. Thanks for your comment George. Ah well just another lesson learned on this wonderful journey called life. Jesus wasnt a Jew, and look how He was torn to shreds because his credibility was questioned. 2 Corinthians 10:5 We demolish arguments and every pretension that sets itself up against the knowledge of God, and we take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ. Store | Dr. Caroline Leaf - Dr. Leaf This proverb was written as a reminder that what we dwell on becomes reality. Its also in the blog posts and answers that Ive given to the same question over the years. Then my kids would close their eyes tight and put their little hands over their ears. What I think is important is to ask whether what Leaf is teaching is steering people away from God or toward God. The data will be used to identify needs and priorities, benchmark against various population characteristics, evaluate programs and policies, plan for services and programs, and advocate for resources. Heather Riggleman is a believer, wife, mom, author, social media consultant, and full-time writer. Review: Switch On Your Brain by Caroline Leaf People who hold this view are called materialists. Everyone has their own personal perspective and thats fine. In the videos I've watched, she has totally twisted Scripture. Please, just tell me if River Valley Church is a name it and claim it organization, and we can save a lot of time! [1: p33,38]. Sharper than any double-edged sword, it penetrates even to Read: 1 Corinthians 3:16, Ephesians 2:10, 3 John 1:2. Now, two years of intense research, dozens of posts and a book later, people are starting to take notice. Be on the lookout for an email announcing it later this summer! She must have her facts straight if she is preaching at some of the biggest churches on the planet, right? I have listened to a couple of her blogs, but they did not resonate with me. C3 Womens Conference: A Leaf out of whosebook? Well Ill conclude by offering a piece of worldly advice life is fleeting. Leaf's experience, also see her. Dr Leafs teachings are not supported by science, nor by scripture. Luke 10:20. Satisfy yourself about where the truth lies. And if she cant be trusted with the most basic of facts about herself, how can she be trusted with anything else? Dr. Caroline Leaf is a communication pathologist and cognitive neuroscientist whose passion is to help people see the power of the mind to change the brain and find their purpose in life. A year or so ago I did her detoxification of the toxic thoughts. The conscious mind works only when we are awake. On a final note, know that I am not against healing! 10. BVOV - Apr2123 - The Christian Chain of Command Serves Others From the NIV, I am reminded of your sincere faith, which first lived in your grandmother Lois and in your mother Eunice and, I am persuaded, now lives in you also. Leaf's books and materials are intended to serve as guidelines for managing toxic thoughts, emotions, and bodies and not as a replacement for professional medical advice. Also I am not implying mental illness is a sin but God does help people in this area through doctors , Jesus, loving others etc. Actually I noticed the same things he or she did and whilst reading the same posts he was referring to, I did sense that you were not being nice. Much of this work is highlighted in her books and we are currently in development of a historical timeline outlining these applied projects and their results to showcase Dr. Leafs historical research on the website. I put my trust in you, and I know you will give me the sleep I need to be energized for the day tomorrow. You will also learn how to detox . If you pray with faith quoting the scripture in first person because God has not given me a spirit of fear, but of power of love and a sound mind immediately the anxiety goes away because anxiety is caused by fear the power of God, the Love of God and the sound mind of God given to us by Him can drive away fear and whatever else fear causes including anxiety, stress or depression which is coursed by fear NOT that anxiety is fear. Supported by current scientific and medical research, Dr. Caroline Leaf gives listeners a prescription for better health and wholeness through correct thinking patterns, declaring that we are not victims of our biology. She uses this little factoid all the time to justify her belief in the power of thoughts. And we are not perfect. If you want a formal meeting or statement from Pastor Rob and the Elders that will come after we meet if needed. My greater concern is that we are once again addressing this topic of healing. Results revealed statistically increased levels of awareness, autonomy, and empowerment and significantly decreased toxic mental health factors. They stop sharing their opinions because they get ignored or ostracised. Take for example, the treatment of depression. Many of us think that once our life is transformed, then our mind will be renewed. The mind is what the brain does, and we see the uniqueness of each mind through our gifts. I appreciate that youve considered all sides and are looking for the best in both. All the churches and Christians, myself being one, have swallowed her hook, line, and sinker. It is actually the other way around. Caroline Leaf, Switch On Your Brain: The Key to Peak Happiness, Thinking, and Health 16 likes Like "We are not victims of our biology. Dr. Caroline Leaf 3y A Conversation with Bishop T.D. 1:7). Leaf & toxic thoughts, enter these terms into your YouTube search box: Caroline Leaf toxic thoughts. Its only when good people speak up that the truth has a chance to win over. March 16, 2015. Most of the information from this article was taken fromthe video below. I copied the link to your TEDx commentary and sent an email to her producer as there was no where else to put it. This is not founded in biblical truth and I am very uncomfortable being here listening to afalse interpretation of scripture with New Age twist Good news: Leaf has a handy five-step process for changing your brain (with an emphasis on mindfulness, it turns out.) The primary aim of these trials is to make mental health care more affordable, applicable, and accessible worldwide, and to reduce the stigma around mental health. People have been questioning my salvation ever since I started reviewing Dr Leafs work its as if most of the Christian church consider salvation and intelligence to be mutually exclusive. About six months ago, carolyn Leaf showed up at my church. Surely theres nothing to reappraise? Lets call it for what it is opinion. Ill make my own choices led by The Holy Spirit who guides us in all Truth. She also makes money from the sale of books she has authored and a "21 day Brain Detoxification Package" she sells online for $19.00. I admire those with the courage to not only ask questions but to strive for answers, and not just accept the superficial, but are willing to peel the layers back and look underneath. But beware of false prophets they profit from your lack of understanding. Even though our brains have around 100 billion brain cells, individual cells can be seen with an electron microscope. The others (2 25%) come from exposure to chemicals in food, etc. This suggests a topic called Mind (or Religious) Science, basically suggesting that man can control his own destiny. This is the one who produces a crop, yielding a hundred, sixty or thirty times what was sown.". These results show the promise of the NeurocycleTM as a stress management and instructional efficacy support tool for educators that also provides a medium for measuring results and maintenance. That Dr Leaf also regularly misquotes her sources and relies on unpublished opinion from pseudoscientists and new-age practitioners also brings her reputation as an expert scientist into disrepute. Quantitative Electroencephalography (QEEG) Assessment of the NeurocycleTM. That can change to amushroom within 21 days. Perhaps you could give us that evidence, otherwise its just hear-say. Cleaning Up Your Mental Mess by Dr. Caroline Leaf Switch On Your Brain, LLC and the author specifically disclaim any and all liability arising directly or indirectly from the use or application of any information contained in these materials. Ok, well I will look further and read your post again. All rights reserved. Simply having some training in neuroanatomy and psychology doesnt make you a cognitive neuroscientist. In 2 Peter 2:1-3, Peter notes that there are many false prophets that we need to be wary of. Please show us the science! PLoS medicine 2010;7(11):e1000361. No costume the Emperor had worn before was ever such a complete success.. Leaf began developing her Neurocycle and Metacog system for mind management. This Diatribe is so lengthy, youve worked very hard to convince yourself of something other than the truth. Get on your knees. 1st ed. Your position is certainly very gracious, even magnanimous. That bothered me a lot, but I ignored it cause I was getting myself back on track. All the best to you. It is a very insightful review. As they got older, that same phrase also encompassed a new aspect about their thought life with the verse, Be careful how you think; your life is shaped by your thoughts, (Proverbs 4:23 GNT). She teaches that thoughts cause stress, when again, the evidence is the opposite psychological stress starts as a subconscious process which changes our stream of thoughts. Leaf's research started 38 years ago with her masters thesis and her PhD dissertation work. In our superposition with God, we are in a position to collect a probability which has not happened in our lives into an actuality. In our superposition, we need to be glad not in our works, but that our names are written in the lambs book of life and that we are being saved, and will be saved. Its up to you entirely as to whether you agree with me, and to be perfectly honest, Im not bothered either way. A communication pathologist is an allied health professional which seems to be unique to South Africa where Dr Leaf trained. She has helped patients learn how to use their minds to detox, and grow their brains to succeed in every area of their lives, including schools, universities, and workplaces. I know people personally with mental illness, and scitsophrenia. Please take the time to tell outline your concerns about Dr Leaf to your friends, social media followers, and the pastors of the church you saw her at. To be honest, I started reading her books with the same assumption in mind. Well Im happy to tell you that we had the same kind of results The minute that the teachers actually started applying the techniques, we altered the trend significantly. and, Thanks for sharing your opinion. The neurobiology of moral behavior: review and neuropsychiatric implications. We can, however, become a part of the healing process by thinking about, whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is admirableif anything is excellent or praiseworthythink about such things. (Philippians 4:8). She has endorsements from Joyce Meyer, Bobbie Houston, and a number of other pre-eminent Christian pastors. But this isnt just getting some minor facts wrong. Teacher Survey (Steiner & Woo, 2021) have revealed that job-related stresses, which have been amplified with COVID-19 measures, are critically threatening the teacher supply. Another example, on the 26 May 2014 on her social media feeds, Dr Leaf said, James 1:21 How you react to events and circumstances of your life is based upon your perceptions and then a week later, James 1:21 Our thoughts and perceptions have a direct and overwhelmingly significant effect of the cells of our body (4/6/2014). Learn how your comment data is processed. Quantum physics scripture/Dr Caroline Leaf In her books and on social media, Dr Leaf often quotes scripture in an attempt to reinforce her reputation as some form of Biblical expert. I dont downplay that at all. All I can say is, good luck and all the best to you. Our pastors and leaders vouch for Dr Leafs teaching because its been endorsed by world-renowned Christian leaders like Kenneth Copeland and Joyce Meyer. . I contend that its very important that were not wilfully ignorant. I thank you, Abba, that you are my protector. So, you may have to write it down in your calendar and tell yourself that your strong habit will be established on, say, October 20. Throughout his ministry on earth of making all things new, healing was central to his mission because one of the main consequences of the fall was sickness and disease. To reiterate, I am not frustrated with the Lifegroup, and I think _____________ Church has an excellent and balanced ministry. Change you behaviour from praise to worship. Leaf is focused on sharing her findings in academic publications, including upcoming peer-reviewed articles on the benefits of the Neurocycle as shown by clinical research using blood measures and QEEG tests, psychometric validation of her Leaf Mind Management (LMM) scale as a mindfulness measurement tool, studies in partnership with US school districts confirming the Neurocycles utility as a mind management intervention and learning support tool for teachers and students, and a longitudinal study of thousands of Neurocycle app users mental health improvement using the Neurocycle program. But I am against man trying to be God and exalting himself to that level. Dr. We have been trying to get her back on the meds since the Tuesday night Lifegroup, but I cannot shove them down her throat. If you want to decorate your pious judgement up with scripture, thats your call. Leaf. Dr. Leafs passion for improving mental health and learning led her to focus her early career in clinical and community settings to get her program to as many people as possible. I will be healthy in order to shine a light wherever you send me, at home or in the workplace. As you have requested, I have not copied other RVC staff on this email. Leaf is nice. Thank you, Thank so much for writing this. Please discuss specific symptoms and medical conditions with your doctor. Her influence continues to grow. The current research study seeks to answer this call. Switch on Your Brain by Dr. Caroline Leaf - Audiobook - Audible.com